I’ve tasted many cookies in my short life. Some bad, some good, some undercooked, some crispy, some with nuts, some without…And I’ve come to a few conclusions about Chocolate Chip Cookies, and a recipe that I like the best.
Tip #1: Not all chocolate chips are the same.
When making something as amazing and comforting as chocolate chip cookies, I believe in using a good chocolate chip. Some have more cocoa than others, and some are smoother than others. Here’s my ranking of semi-sweet chips I have tried, from best to worst:
- Ghiradelli
- Hershey’s
- Nestle
- Store Brand
I never actually bought and made a batch with the Ghiradelli, but I have tried them and they are quite amazing. However, a compromise between quality and price usually dictates that I get the Hershey’s, which is still very smooth and tastes more chocolatey. The only reason I first tried them was because they were out of stock of the Nestle….but once I tried them, I would never go back. The price difference isn’t big enough for as much as I actually make cookies, so I just get the Hershey’s.
Tip #2: Use whole-wheat flour for the best flavor
Really, if you haven’t started using whole-wheat flour in everything by now, you really should. I don’t care if white flour is cheaper; that doesn’t mean it’s better OR better for you. That’s my philosophy on buying other types of breads, as well as things like pasta and frozen convenience foods. You can read a little bit more about “whole wheat” labeling on foods here.
If you just start doing whole wheat with everything, you’ll get used to the taste. When I first started eating whole-wheat pasta a few years ago, I thought it was really weird, but since I knew it was better for me, I just kept getting it. Now white pasta tastes really weird to me.
By the way, there’s a difference between “wheat” and “whole wheat,” which you can read about here. Basically, something labeled “wheat,” or containing “wheat flour” on the ingredients means that the flour was not made with the whole kernel of wheat. Something labeled “100% Whole Wheat” or listed as “Whole Wheat” on the ingredients means that the flour was made from the whole kernel of wheat. And since ingredients lists are required to list the stuff in rank of proportion, something that has “Whole wheat” as the first ingredient is the best for you. And the benefits of whole wheat/whole grain consumption? More fiber! Lower cholesterol! And thus, lowering your risk of heart diseases, obesity, and diabetes, among others.
Tip #3: Balsamic vinegar
Not even kidding. Vinegar brings out the flavor of chocolate. Balsamic is also kind of sweet, so that’s what I like to use. Schlotsky’s sells some amazing balsamic vinegar, by the way. Also, there is some Raspberry-balsamic vinegar made by Regina that we recently got at the store, and that is amazing on salads and in marinades, though I haven’t tried it in the cookies. It’s just mixed with raspberry juice, but it’s even more fruity.
Tip #4: Activate the gluten in the flour
This will make the cookies stay softer for longer, and you do this by mixing the flour with a bit of water before adding it to the other ingredients. Since I’m usually too lazy and don’t want to have to wash another bowl, I usually don’t do this. When I do, though, I can tell a difference. Matt can too, even when I don’t tell him I did the water trick. Definitely do it though, if you plan on sending someone cookies in the mail or you’re making a lot of cookies several days in advance of a particular holiday or event.
Tip #5: Only bake one cookie sheet at a time
It may take a while longer, but the air circulates better around one sheet rather than two. The cookies will be baked more evenly and that means you know every time exactly how long you need to set the timer.
Oven temps and times may vary. What I put in the recipe below is the perfect amount of time on my oven for the level of softness and done-ness that I like (which is: completely cooked dough in the middle, yet still soft and chewy). We’re also fortunate to have a digital thermometer and timer on the oven, so it’s a bit more precise. We didn’t have one like that before we moved, so I would just watch it until the cookies were golden brown around the edges and starting to firm up towards the center.
The Recipe:
This is modified from the Nestle/Hershey’s recipe (they’re the same recipe on the back of the bag of chips).
- 1 c. salted butter, softened (2 sticks)
- 1/2 tsp salt
- 3/4 c. white sugar
- 3/4 c. brown sugar
- 1 tsp vanilla
- 1/2 Tbs balsamic vinegar
- 2 large eggs
- 1 tsp baking soda
- 2 1/4 c. whole-wheat flour
- [Optional: few Tbs. of water]
- bag of Hershey’s semi-sweet chocolate chips
- Optional: chopped nuts, cinnamon, or raisins (seriously, they taste good with chocolate!)
Cream the butter, salt, sugar, baking soda, and wet ingredients with a mixer. [Add a few table spoons of water to the flour and mix well.] Add the flour to the butter and stir in chips. Place tablespoonfuls on a good air-bake cookie sheet. Bake at 375 F for about 10 minutes. Remove from cookie sheet immediately and place on a cooling rack.
Two Random and Useful Ideas:
#1: Double or triple a batch and freeze whatever you don’t want to bake that day in a plastic bag. When you know you’re going to have guests over, you can take the bag out, let it sit for about 10 minutes, scoop what you need onto a cookie sheet, and pop it into the oven. And there you go, fresh baked cookies for your guests without all the prep and mess!
#2: Frozen, baked cookies are pretty good straight from the freezer, as is cookie dough.
I hope this was a helpful post. Enjoy your cookies!